Photo credit: Gerry Broome/AP
By Dylan Howlett (@DylanHowlett)
If he should need any further reminder of his profession’s tenuous nature, its unwieldy expectations, its capricious journey, Carolina Hurricanes head coach Kirk Muller...
Photo credit: Gerry Broome/AP
By Dylan Howlett (@DylanHowlett)
If he should need any further reminder of his profession’s tenuous nature, its unwieldy expectations, its capricious journey, Carolina Hurricanes head coach Kirk Muller need look no further than to his immediate left and right. There stand Dave Lewis and John MacLean, current Carolina assistants and cautionary tales of the enduringly bizarre realm of NHL coaching.
Muller’s seat in Raleigh is barely lukewarm, percolating by the most fatalistic standards. He has steered the Canes to a 44-45-16 record and zero playoff berths since replacing Paul Maurice in November 2011, adequate considering the circumstances — midseason hire, a roster in transition — but hardly exemplary.
Muller was one of the league’s most coveted coaching candidates when Carolina General Manager Jim Rutherford plucked him from the American Hockey League’s Milwaukee Admirals and booted Maurice. An assistant for five seasons with the Montreal Canadiens, Muller quickly accrued a reputation as a stout tactician. He devised the stifling schemes that successfully neutralized Alex Ovechkin and Sidney Crosby in the 2010 Stanley Cup Playoffs, vaulting the eighth-seeded Habs into the Eastern Conference Final.
But a decorated resumé stands little chance against the paper-thin patience of GMs, owners and fans who clamor for instant success as if it were a birthright. Woe, too, to the head coach who can be supplanted instantaneously by a more alluring candidate.
Kirk Muller, center, is constantly surrounded by reminders of a head coach’s vulnerability (Credit: Getty Images).
That’s precisely the scenario that befell Lewis in Detroit. The former defenseman led the Red Wings to consecutive Central Division crowns in 2002-03 and 2003-04, having been awarded the unenviable task of succeeding the immortal Scotty Bowman. But Detroit sputtered in the playoffs, falling in 2003 to Anaheim in the first round and losing once more to the Mighty Ducks in the second round a year later. Mike Babcock, the upstart head coach who guided the once-hapless Ducks to the 2003 Stanley Cup Final, began searching for a more prestigious post following Anaheim’s elimination from the 2004 playoffs.
Lewis — a mainstay on the Joe Lewis Arena bench since 1987 as a longtime assistant — was out of luck, and soon out of a job.
The Red Wings hired Babcock, won the Stanley Cup in 2008, and came one goal short of a second straight championship in 2009. Lewis would serve one more coaching stint in the NHL in 2006-07, fired after one season in Boston for failing to make the playoffs.
There are, of course, extenuating circumstances, factors beyond the coach’s control that should absolve him of the sins of an underachieving team — “should” being the operative word, or in the case of NHL head coaching, entirely optional.
Muller can reasonably invoke such circumstances. He has yet to oversee a full training camp, negotiating the delicate tasks of taking over a team in the middle of a season and cobbling together a cogent plan amid a lockout-condensed schedule. Muller did his level best in 2013, as did his team, which led its division into March before goalie Cam Ward and defensemen Justin Faulk and Joni Pitkanen joined the MASH unit, taking the Canes’ playoff aspirations with them.
“We just weren’t able to overcome the injuries to key guys that we lost,” Muller said after Carolina was eliminated from contention, a valid point if not for the inconvenient truth that coaching is hardly fair nor reasonable nor logical. There are few excuses that can absolve all sins.
MacLean was as diligent in pursuing a head coaching job as his ex-teammate Muller. He was an assistant coach with the Devils for six seasons. He coached New Jersey’s AHL affiliate for a full season, more experience than Muller could boast, having accepted Rutherford’s offer two months into his first